The first release for New Zealand jukebox-pop
revisionists The Brunettes was a seven-inch single called
"Mars Loves Venus," the song and the band at the time
telling the tale of Brunettes co-conspirators Jonathan
Bree and Heather Mansfield, their lovin' love-in happily
casting them as some sort of new-millennial Phil and
Ronnie. Six years later, they borrow the same title,
and that title song, for their second longplayer; but
with so much water under the bridge, here they evoke
the same phrase with an entirely different intent.
The first time around, when Bree
and Mansfield were singing bubblegum jukebox odes with
stars in their eyes, the fluttering eyelids didn't lie;
the clashing lashes were merely flutterings mirroring
the dum-dum-diddy of their fast-beating hearts. By their
debut disc, with this main couple having gone their
separate ways off the court, the back-and-forth boy/girl
exchanges had taken on a different quality, either reflecting
their relationship at that stage, or playing out the
kind of relationships these producers and their ingūnues
had back in the girl-group day, or, even, playing the
naivete of the past against the cynicism of the present.
On that first album, "Holding Hands, Feeding Ducks",
Mansfield maintained the cutesy-pie girl-group spirit
in her singing, whilst Bree acted more disaffected and
detached, standing back at an all-knowing distance and
taking a snide tone that, within the songs, went over
the girl-with-the-curl's head.
For their second album, they've
borrowed the title of that first single, although, with
this "Mars Loves Venus", it's obvious how
times have changed wholly from those salad days, sure,
but even greatly from that first-up longplayer. Here,
the female voice is brought forward into the (post-)
modern day, talking from an empowered now of self-help
speak (hence the Mars and Venus of the title) and girl-power
catchphrases. So, then, when, in "Leonard Says," when
the girl tries to cheer her depressed boy, her perkiness
isn't devoted and eternal, responding to his day-to-day
despondence ("I sure don't want to be 30-something and
work in a record store... paranoid I'm just getting
bitter and old") with a defined, quietly defiant stand:
"Please don't scare me like that ever again/ I won't
be an audience for you self-aggression/ And if you wanna
be my lover/ You've gotta get with my friends." True
to such, when Bree takes on a teasing tone, here, he
gets an immediate reaction. "These Things Take Time"
begins with Mansfield honking out some rudimentary clarinet,
which leads to the boy/girl lyrical swapping "These
things take time, like learning the clarinet/'You know
I'm trying but I'm so impatient'/ It's getting better,
week by week you hardly ever squeak/ 'Yeaaaahhh, whatever!'"
Later, "Your Heart Dies" finds his "not everyone's lawn
gets mowed twice a week" met by an aggressive "what's
that supposed to mean?" from her. It's that same song
that finds them happily recalling their relationship
(together, in harmony) as "Once you were a trophy for
me/ As luck would have it, I, a trophy for you": taking
that old-fashioned convention of the smart guy with
the pretty wife and twisting it to fit modern social
conventions, the smart people who're just as swayed
by prettiness, finding mutual trophy-wife-isms in each
other. At that point of the song the closing track
on this disc all suddenly stops; and, in the silence,
Mansfield whispers, in her New Zealand accent (which
counters the deliberate faux-Americanism of Bree's crooning),
"It's unavoidable, it just happens; when you grow up,
your heart dies."
So, yes, whilst The Brunettes
spend so much of their time evoking the '60s as viewed
through the prism of Shadow Morton's teenaged pop-song
soap-operas they did come of age in the '80s, and
echoing one of the signature lines from John Hughes's
teenaged motion-picture soap-opera "The Breakfast Club"
shows that much. Placed in this context, its sentiments
go hand in hand with the ideas of struggling to grow
up, and cultivating nostalgia for one's youth that were
addressed in "Leonard Says" (these two of the many songs
on the album to evoke the "movies" in some form). Taken,
as whole, it seems to speak of Bree's discomfort at
making eternally-youthful music when he himself is aging.
Having lived the rock-'n'-roll teenaged-rebellion life,
starting the first rarely-spoken-of incarnation of The
Brunettes when he was 14 [JB was actually 18! - Ed],
Bree now finds himself, at 25, drifting away from an
age where he can legitimately identify with teenaged
soap-operas. That the Brunettes have been able to grow
to take in all of these growing-up feelings speaks volumes
of their take on pop music, the combo less a novelty
act than an exploration of the then-and-now of popular
song, the then-and-now of the songwriter's life, and
the then-and-now of the songwriters' entwined lives.